Charlie Chaplin’s A Day’s Pleasure (1919)

Charlie Chaplin’s A Day’s Pleasure (1919)

Chaplin’s A Day’s Pleasure called Charlie’s Picnic is an excursion in San Pedro harbor. It’s not a picnic, and Chaplin preferred A Day’s Pleasure as an ironic title because the story is a series of ironic misfortunes: seasickness, fistfights, and a return home that...
D.H. Lawrence’s Women in Love (1920)

D.H. Lawrence’s Women in Love (1920)

“How lovely it is to be free,” said Ursula, running swiftly here and there between the tree trunks, quite naked, her hair blowing loose. The grove was of beech trees, big and splendid, a steel-grey scaffolding of trunks and boughs, with level sprays of...
Roy C. Smallwood’s Camille; A Modernized Version (1921)

Roy C. Smallwood’s Camille; A Modernized Version (1921)

Smallwood’s picnic episode is not in Dumas, fils’s La Dame aux Camélias. According to Smallwood’s cinematic logic, however, romantic scenes in a natural setting are sure audience winners. The screen legend tells the obvious, “Love is the...
Erich von Stroheim’s Greed (1924)

Erich von Stroheim’s Greed (1924)

Von Stroheim’s picnic at Schuetzen Park is a loose adaptation of Frank Norris’s episode in McTeague. For the film, von Stroheim does not provide the food details. In the novel McTeague, Norris describes the Sieppe’s abundant picnic: clam chowder,...
King Vidor’s La Bohème (1926)

King Vidor’s La Bohème (1926)

Vidor’s picnic in La Bohème narrates the critical moment when Mimi and Rodolpho fall in love. It’s absent from the screenplay’s sources: Puccini’s opera La Bohème and Henri Muger’s Scenes de la vie bohème (Scenes of Bohemian Life). The legend tells that   Her first...
Laurel & Hardy’s Perfect Day (1929)

Laurel & Hardy’s Perfect Day (1929)

Laurel and Hardy’s A Perfect Day is a picnic screw-up. The day begins with smiles, but nothing goes right, and they never get far from home. The picnic is an unfulfilled dream. *Compare this with Charlie Chaplin’s slapstick A Day’s Pleasure posted...
Josef von Sternberg’s An American Tragedy (1931)

Josef von Sternberg’s An American Tragedy (1931)

Dreiser disapproved of von Sternberg’s An American Tragedy. He argued Von Sternberg and screenwriter Samuel Hoffenstein played down the grinding forces of social and financial pressures and accentuated the love story of Clyde Griffiths’ infatuation with a wealthy...
Tod Browning’s Freaks (1932)

Tod Browning’s Freaks (1932)

Rumor has it that at a studio script reading of Browning’s Freaks, Irving Thalberg, MGM’s production head, is reputed to exclaim, “I asked for something horrifying. Well, I got it.” But when Freaks was released, it failed. Unlike...
Norman Z. McLeod’s It’s a Gift (1934)

Norman Z. McLeod’s It’s a Gift (1934)

McLeod’s It’s a Gift is a testament to W.C. Fields’s comic skill at making a picnic an utterly messy war zone. On their way west to California, the Bissonettes pronounced bis-on-nay and stopped for picnic lunch. Blithely ignoring a “Private...